[Home]R3m0t Rating System

Diana Wynne Jones Wiki Home | RecentChanges | Preferences

Showing revision 5
Climax: 5 = Climax (Magicians of Caprona), 1 = Anti-climax (Homeward Bounders)

Thought: 5 = V Good (Power of Three, Hexwood), 1 = Bad (Stealer of Souls)

r3m0t: Any other ideas? I want this to be finished and balanced before I actually start using it.

LR: Depends on what you like about DWJ, but you might want a humour scale.

r3m0t: I don't really notice humour much in DWJ (not that it doesn't exist) - I usually read the ones in which I lose myself. I have noticed, though, that [Time of the Ghost]? is more sinister compared to, say, [Homeward Bounders]?, which is more serious than Power of Three, which is more serious than Mixed Magics - some of which are officially listed as for the same age group.

LR: Hmmm fair enough, although part of my enjoyment of, say, Howl's Moving Castle, is that I find the antics of Sophie and her situations tickle me. It's not strongly explicit humour but it still makes me smile.

Diana Wynne Jones Wiki Home | RecentChanges | Preferences
This page is read-only | View other revisions | View current revision
Edited June 19, 2003 10:14 am by 212.18.248.xxx (diff)
Anyone can edit the DWJ wiki. To edit the DWJ wiki, edit the Preferences and enter the Administrator password (not the first password field, the second password field) 'cennoreth'.